Who's Got Your View?

Should The View have men too?

October 4, 2010
Elizabeth Hasselbeck, Whoopi Goldberg, Barbara Walters, Joy Behar, Sherri ShSource: Stephen Lovekin/Getty

The women of The View: Elizabeth Hasselbeck, Whoopi Goldberg, Barbara Walters, Joy Behar, and Sherri Shepherd.

Share This Story

The other night, up late, I ended up watching Late Night with Jimmy Fallon whose guest was Christopher Meloni of Law & Order: SVU. OK, I admit, I've long been a fan of Meloni's and of SVU, actually all the Law & Orders, so maybe it wasn't an "accident," but that's another story.

After the usual chat, the two men sat down to a card game of War, with a twist. They had to throw a glass of water in the other's face when a play was lost while wearing those old-fashioned bathing caps with plastic flowers that your grandmother used to wear.

Yes, it was funny. Yes, I laughed. But I also thought, 'Women would never do this.'

Cut to The View — well, not literally, but that's where my mind went because of the recent hubbub about a male version of The View.

Why, I thought? There are lots of men's talk shows and panel shows (Wanda Sykes, the sole female late night host, was quickly canceled).

The View broke new ground too, because they have a panel of women skirting the default demarcation of traditional female fare: fashion, home, and celebrity stuff — instead having heated discussions on politics and other topical issues of the day. First Lady Michelle Obama was a guest, but so, recently was President Obama.

True, Jimmy Fallon is a comedian, but so are three of The View's panelists, Whoopi Goldberg, Joy Behar, and Sherri Shepherd. And we don't see them (or Elizabeth Hasselbeck, who's married to a football player) — in a similar vein to the bathing cap/ water-War game — donning football helmets and running at the Stay-Puft Marshmallow Man.

A Daily News story discussing Barbara Walter's intent to put together a male version of The View led with,

Think of it as "The View" — with chest hair.

and cited dream draft picks:

At the top of their list, we're told, is former "Today" show host Bryant Gumbel, as the show's moderator. "He brings the same kind of vibe as Meredith Vieira when she was one of the co-hosts," says the source.
The other male [they] have in mind would balance Gumbel's reserve with a splash of flamboyance: Filipino-American comedian Alec Mapa, who played newscaster Suzuki St. Pierre on "Ugly Betty." The insider says Mapa did so well on his first appearance on "The View" that he was brought back as a guest host."

So my question is, do you want a male View? Some do. Is the male View for you? Or for an audience of Mr. Moms and out-of-work husbands?

What's your view?

Share Your Thoughts

For your protection, ensure that no personally identifiable information (like full name or email address) is submitted in your comment.

CAPTCHA
This tests that you are really a person and not a computer.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

Your Privacy

Trust is a cornerstone of our corporate mission, and the success of our business depends on it. P&G is committed to maintaining your trust by protecting personal information we collect about you, our consumers.
Lovepo | Oct 10, 2010

The view is not my cup of tea,and they do not speak for all American women! I am one that does not care for the advice and opinions of the women who make up "the view". I will not watch it at all anymore. So, if you produce a show that has "all men giving advice and opinions" the show has to be a hundred times better and interesting than those women. So, go for it,make it interesting and fun,anything will beat what ba ba has to say and the rest of her panel. I am up for a good laugh and a better show than "the view". Hope it knocks the socks right off of them.

Anonymous | Oct 4, 2010
No,no,no.....don't let them invade our space. Have a male once in a while ( just so he can humiliate himself..sorry Bill) but keep "The View" for the women. Girl power!!!!
Anonymous | Oct 4, 2010
My view is that the show will be a big flop. As you say, there are plenty of places to watch men talk to each other. I'd be more interested in watching a co-ed show with regulars and which brought a "real" person into the mix every week. For one week, a high school teacher, for one week, a civil engineer, for one week a lawyer. Of course, they'd have to be interviewed and screened to make sure they had something to say and could do it in "exalted" company, but I think that would generate buzz.

follow us

Subscribe to Newsletters
X


© NBC Universal Inc. All Rights Reserved  |  Part of the iVillage Lifestyle Network
LifeGoesStrong® is a registered trademark of Procter & Gamble